UKFREE SPEECH

Google Refuses UK Request to Pull Russell Brand Prison Message

His wife read out his claim of innocence to 6.6 million subscribers. The government asked YouTube to delete it – and was told no rules had been broken.

Russell Brand speaking at the Cambridge Union Society
Russell Brand at the Cambridge Union Society (archive). Photo: Cantab12 / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

The British government asked Google to take down a YouTube video in which jailed comedian Russell Brand insists he is innocent – and Google said no. The company refused the request because the clip did not break its rules, Whitehall sources told the BBC. On Thursday, housing minister Matthew Pennycook admitted the state has no power to force the issue.

Brand was sentenced last week to ten and a half years in prison after a jury convicted him of rape and three counts of sexual assault against four women. On Sunday, his wife Laura read out a message from him on the couple’s YouTube channel, which has 6.6 million subscribers: “I am not guilty of the offences I have been jailed for.” By Thursday the video had been seen around 850,000 times. The Prison Service asked for it to be removed, saying it was offensive to his victims and had reached a large audience, and the Ministry of Justice opened an investigation into whether Brand broke prison rules.

“We don’t have any power to mandate a removal of content. That is up to Google. It’s based on their terms and conditions.”

— Matthew Pennycook, UK housing minister
We don’t have any power to mandate a removal of content. That is up to Google. It’s based on their terms and conditions.
Matthew Pennycook, UK housing minister

“Show some decency”

Prime Minister Andy Burnham urged social media firms to “show some decency and take these videos down”. Google said only that it was aware of the content and investigating, adding that Brand’s channel has been barred from earning money on YouTube since September 2023. Former safeguarding minister Jess Phillips told the BBC the government “doesn’t have the power” to enforce removal, and the Guardian reports that a new law may be needed. Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch said she would not immediately demand that Google delete the video.

Not everyone wants it gone. Former MP @ABridgen welcomed Google’s decision on X, warning that the government was trying to make Brand an “unperson” in the language of Orwell’s 1984, and asked which law allows ministers to demand the removal of a convicted person’s posts. Prisoners in England and Wales are banned from making statements that distress victims, and Brand could face restrictions on calls and visits if he is found to have broken that rule.

What happens next

Next: the Ministry of Justice is still in “dialogue” with Google, and its investigation could limit Brand’s phone calls and visits from prison.

Share on X