NORWAYJUSTICE
Supreme Court Quashes Jail Term for Man Whose ‘Racist Attack’ Claim Sparked Torch Marches
Hamse Ali said five to seven men beat him in a Bergen park. Police say he was riding past on an e-scooter. Now the case goes back to the appeal court for a third round.

The man whose story of a racist beating in Bergen led to torch marches will get a new trial. On Thursday, Norway’s Supreme Court overturned the appeal court ruling that had sentenced Hamse Ali to 45 days in prison for giving a false statement to police, NRK reports. The case must now be heard again by the court of appeal, next year according to Uten Filter.
In the autumn of 2024, Ali told police he had been attacked by five to seven unknown men in Nygårdsparken in Bergen and that the violence was racially motivated. The story caused strong reactions, and torch marches were held against racism and in his support. But the police investigation found that he had not been in the park at the time. Instead, his e-scooter had raced through central Bergen before stopping abruptly at Vågsallmenningen, and police found a picture of the scooter outside the emergency clinic on his own phone.
“Straff etter første ledd kommer ikke til anvendelse mot en mistenkt som forklarer seg uriktig om det forhold mistanken mot ham gjelder.”
“Punishment under the first paragraph does not apply to a suspect who gives a false statement about the matter he is suspected of.”
— Norwegian Penal Code, section 221, the rule at the heart of the appeal
Straff etter første ledd kommer ikke til anvendelse mot en mistenkt som forklarer seg uriktig om det forhold mistanken mot ham gjelder.
“Punishment under the first paragraph does not apply to a suspect who gives a false statement about the matter he is suspected of.”
Can you lie to protect yourself?
The district court acquitted him, accepting expert evidence that a head injury from the scooter fall combined with heavy drinking could have created false memories. The court of appeal disagreed and convicted him. At the Supreme Court, the question was narrower: whether Ali could be punished for false statements in follow-up interviews, when telling the truth would have incriminated him.
The Supreme Court ruled that a person may in some cases repeat an earlier false account without punishment if that is necessary to avoid revealing his own offence – but not freely build on the lie with new false details. It found the appeal court had read the law correctly but had not explained well enough why Ali’s elaborations were punishable, noting that it may matter which questions police asked and whether he volunteered the information. Ali has maintained throughout that he told police what he remembered. Norwegian outlet @utenfilter_no called it a saga that continues.
What happens next
Next: a completely new appeal-court hearing is expected next year.



